Love It or Toss It, #4

My makeup collection continues to grow and it is becoming harder and harder for me to purge items from my collection. (Yup, I did a pretty good purge a few weeks ago, but there is still more to do! All these pretties have to have a loving home if I'm not making use of them!) So I figured it was about time to do another edition of Love It or Toss It! (See all of the previous #loveitortossit posts here.)

Revlon Lip Butter in Berry Smoothie review, Becca Eye Tint in Baroque Review, Nars Lipstick in Damage review

Affiliate Links

Revlon Lip Butter in Berry Smoothie
I remember when these first came out, I was so excited to try out this creamy drugstore formula. I bought two as soon as I saw them in stores, and I wore them maybe once or twice and then totally forgot about them. These last few days, I've been testing out the formula again and found it to be very comfortable to wear. The pale pink shade is nice, but nothing exciting on my lips. I have another, brighter shade, so I'll hold on to that one!
The Verdict: Toss! 

Becca Eye Tint in Baroque
I was super excited when Becca came to Sephora a year ago and I immediately picked up the Best of Becca Set as an introduction to the brand. I love the creamy texture of Becca Eye Tint as well as the packaging that allows for very specific amounts to be dispensed. Unfortunately, the shade barely shows up on me, though the beige color with subtle shimmer would be great on skintones lighter than mine. It is super natural looking in finish and texture, and I think it would be a perfect eye or cheek contour, but it just barely shows up on me. Sad! I suppose I'll have to check out other shades!
The Verdict: Toss! (A bit easier because I think I've already found a new home for it!)

Nars Lipstick in Damage
After Gummy posted about her mauve-y pinky lipsticks (here) I realized I had Nars Damage and probably had never even used it. Oops, that is the story of my life with my makeup collection. I love the creamy light formula, and the shade is a bit more colorful my lips but better kind of shade. It is not drying at all, and I don't have to be careful when reapplying later in the day. Woohoo, and thanks Gummy for reminding me I had this! 
The Verdict: Love! Yay!

Check out the swatches below. Sorry, I'm terrible at swatches, but I just couldn't get good face shots of some of these! 

Swatches L-R: Revlon Lip Butter in Berry Smoothie, Becca Eye Tint in Baroque, Nars Lipstick in Damage

What do you think of this round of love it or toss it products? Have you tried any of these? How did they work out for you?? I'd love to know! :)